Organic Beauty Pros and Cons

Have you ever wandered through the beauty aisle and been overwhelmed by the array of products labeled as ‘organic’ or ‘natural’? If so, you’re not alone! The term “organic beauty” is certainly buzzing, but what does it actually mean? At its core, organic beauty refers to products made with organically grown ingredients, free from synthetic chemicals, GMOs, and harmful pesticides. But as with any trend, there’s more to the story than just the feel-good vibes.

The Health Benefits of Organic Beauty

Starting with the good stuff, let’s dive into some pros of organic beauty. Organic beauty products are known to be gentle on the skin.

Without harsh chemicals or synthetic ingredients, organic products are less likely to cause skin irritations or allergic reactions.

Let’s dig deeper into the kinds of skin irritations or allergic reactions that can be provoked by certain chemicals commonly found in non-organic skincare products.

-Contact Dermatitis

Contact dermatitis is one of the most common skin reactions to skincare products. It happens when your skin “touches” a substance that causes either an allergic reaction or irritates your skin.

In terms of skincare, this can be triggered by a multitude of synthetic ingredients such as parabens (a type of preservative), fragrances, and certain types of alcohol. Symptoms depends on many factors but often are redness, itching, and sometimes even blisters. Patchy, flaky, or scaly skin can also be a sign of contact dermatitis. Organic beauty products, free from such irritants, may help prevent this condition.


Or sun sensitivity, is a reaction that occurs when certain chemicals make your skin more sensitive to sunlight. This can lead to quicker sunburn or skin rash when exposed to the sun. Common culprits in skincare products include certain types of essential oils (like citrus oils), and chemical sunscreens, such as oxybenzone and avobenzone.

Organic beauty products often opt for mineral-based sunscreens (like zinc oxide and titanium dioxide), because they are they prone to cause photosensitivity. However, it’s worth noting that not all organic products are free from photosensitizing ingredients – some organic essential oils can still cause this reaction!!!! (you just have to know the products and use SPF!).

-Acne Cosmetica

Acne triggered by cosmetics! This is commonly caused by pore-clogging ingredients (known as ‘comedogenic’ ingredients) in skincare and makeup products. Examples include certain types of oils, like coconut oil and palm oil, and silicones like dimethicone.

Even organic beauty products can cause acne cosmetica if they contain comedogenic ingredients (like coconut oil!). However, the simplicity of organic ingredients lists can make it easier to spot and avoid these culprits.

In general, it’s important to note that everyone’s skin is different, and reactions can vary widely. Even with organic products, always do a patch test when trying a new product. If you’re experiencing serious or persistent skin issues, it’s best to consult a dermatologist.

Plus, let’s not forget that your skin is your body’s largest organ, so treating it with natural, healthy ingredients just makes sense.

Moreover, organic beauty products are often nutrient-rich. Think of ingredients like olive oil, shea butter, and aloe vera, which are brimming with vitamins and antioxidants. It’s like feeding your skin a healthy salad rather than a processed, fast-food snack.

Let me be clear again, even if you are using organic skincare products, you  still need to know your skin type and what type of ingredients suit you best. For example, I have combination and I cannot stand almost any type of oil, that’s just my skin!).

Positive Impact on the Environment

But it’s not just about you. Organic beauty also benefits Mother Earth. Traditional beauty products can have a significant environmental impact, from the manufacturing process to the final product. Chemicals used in these products often end up in our waterways, harming aquatic life and ecosystems.

However, organic beauty products promote sustainable farming practices. Organic farming doesn’t use synthetic fertilizers or pesticides, reducing soil, water, and air pollution. Plus, many organic beauty brands package their products in recyclable or biodegradable materials to be kinder to the environment.

Ethical Benefits of Organic Beauty

And let’s not forget the feel-good factor. Many organic beauty brands value ethical practices like cruelty-free testing and fair trade (but let’s be honest, not all of them!).  Fair trade is a social movement that aims to ensure producers in developing countries are paid a fair price for their work.

The goal is to minimize poverty, ethically treat farmers, and promote sustainable practices. Fair trade principles include fair payment, good working conditions, no discrimination, and no child labor, to name a few.

Fair trade is regulated and certified through various organizations that establish standards for fair trade practices. Some of the most recognized certifiers globally include Fairtrade International, World Fair Trade Organization, and the Fair Trade Federation.

These organizations conduct audits and provide certifications to businesses that respect fair trade principles. Despite the regulation, it’s crucial for consumers to do their own research, as the quality and strictness of enforcement can vary between different certifiers.

This means you can pamper your skin while also supporting ethical practices and often, local communities.

Debunking controversies: The Cons of Organic Beauty

The ‘Greenwashing’ Dilemma

Now, let’s flip the coin. Despite its virtues, organic beauty isn’t without controversy. A primary concern is the issue of ‘greenwashing.’ This term refers to brands marketing their products as organic or eco-friendly, even when they’re not. Due to inconsistent definitions and regulations around the term ‘organic,’ brands can slap this label on their products without meeting rigorous standards.

Lack of Scientific Backing

Then there’s the scientific debate. Some critics argue that the effectiveness of organic beauty products isn’t backed by substantial research. They point out that synthetic ingredients are often used because they’re effective and stable.

For instance, a common critique is around preservation. Synthetic preservatives ensure that your beauty products don’t harbor harmful bacteria or mold. But organic products, in their quest to be natural, may use alternatives that aren’t as effective, or forego preservatives altogether, leading to shorter shelf lives.

Skincare products, including organic ones, provide a hospitable environment for microorganisms due to their water content, nutrients (like plant extracts and oils), and pH level. Products without preservatives can create an open invitation for the growth of harmful bacteria, yeast, and mold.

The most common types of microorganisms that can contaminate skincare products include:

  • Bacteria: Particularly Pseudomonas aeruginosa and Staphylococcus aureus. Pseudomonas aeruginosa can cause skin and eye infections. Staphylococcus aureus is known for causing infections, abscesses, respiratory infections and even food poisoning.
  • Yeast: Candida species are yeast that, when overgrown, can cause infections in warm, moist areas of the body.
  • Mold: Aspergillus species are a common type of mold that can cause respiratory and skin infections.

If a product is contaminated and used on the skin, these microorganisms could potentially lead to various skin conditions such as dermatitis, folliculitis, or even severe skin infections. Additionally, if such a product is used on broken skin or near the eyes, the risk of more severe infections increases.

To mitigate this risk, some organic skincare brands use natural preservatives like certain essential oils, grapefruit seed extract, or naturally derived substances like Leucidal (a radish root ferment).

However, while these can extend the shelf-life and safety of a product, they are generally not as effective as synthetic preservatives. Thus, it’s important to use organic skincare products within their shelf-life and to store them properly, as per the manufacturer’s instructions. If a product changes color, texture, or smell, it’s best to discontinue use.

It’s worth mentioning that the risk of contamination is a key reason why water-free (anhydrous) products, like certain oils and balms, are popular in organic skincare. Without water, the growth of microorganisms is significantly less likely.

The Cost Factor in Organic Beauty

Organic beauty products often come with higher price tags!

This can make organic beauty feel like a luxury, out of reach for many consumers.

The price differential between organic beauty products and their conventional counterparts can vary significantly, depending on a variety of factors such as the brand, the specific product, and the ingredients used.

A research report published in 2020 by Grand View Research, a U.S.-based market research and consulting company, suggested that on average, organic beauty products can be approximately 20-30% more expensive than conventional beauty products. However, this is a broad estimate and the actual difference can sometimes be much larger.

For example, a conventional drugstore facial cleanser might cost around $10, while an organic facial cleanser from a high-end brand could easily cost $30 or more.

Similarly, a conventional moisturizer might cost around $15, while an organic moisturizer could range from $25 to even $50 or more, depending on the brand and the complexity of the formulation.

The higher cost of organic beauty products is typically due to factors like:

  • Higher cost of organic farming
  • Use of high-quality natural ingredients
  • Sustainable manufacturing processes
  • Ethical labor practices
  • Smaller production quantities

Navigating the Organic Beauty Landscape

Despite these challenges, organic beauty can still be a fantastic choice. The key is to do your homework. Recognize genuine organic beauty brands by researching their practices and looking for certifications from reputable bodies like the USDA, ECOCERT or COSMOS. And remember, every small step towards organic beauty is a step towards healthier skin and a healthier planet.

In conclusion, organic beauty is a balancing act. On one hand, it promises numerous benefits for our skin and the planet. On the other, it’s challenged by controversies that make navigating the organic beauty landscape a tad tricky. But by making informed decisions, we can enjoy the pros while mitigating the cons.

Frequently Asked Questions about Organic Beauty

1. Is organic beauty better for your skin?

Organic beauty products can be better for the skin as they typically avoid harsh chemicals that can cause irritations or allergies. However, everyone’s skin is different, and what works best will vary from person to person.

2. How can I tell if a product is truly organic?

Look for certifications from reputable bodies like the USDA or ECOCERT. These organizations have rigorous standards that a product must meet to be labeled as organic.

3. Why are organic beauty products more expensive?

Organic farming and sustainable manufacturing practices often cost more than conventional methods. This higher cost is typically reflected in the price of organic beauty products.

4. Does organic mean cruelty-free?

Not necessarily. While many organic beauty brands also value ethical practices like cruelty-free testing, the term “organic” specifically refers to how the ingredients were grown and processed.

5. Are organic beauty products always safe?

While organic beauty products avoid many synthetic chemicals, it’s still possible to have allergies or sensitivities to natural ingredients. Always patch test a new product before full use. If you want to learn more about what exactly “organic beauty” means click here.

Avatar photo

Yirlene Mertens

I'll guide you through the maze of skincare options to help you halt the aging process and reclaim your glow.

More to Explore